New York Times Company v. DOD — D.C. Cir. (Nov 16, 2026)
The D.C. Circuit hears New York Times Company versus the Department of Defense, a challenge to the Pentagon's escort rule for reporters. For decades, credentialed reporters could move unescorted through designated parts of the Pentagon, visiting press offices and talking informally with officials. After a court ordered the reinstatement of Times reporters' credentials in March 2026, the Department announced an interim policy the next business day. Journalists could attend arranged briefings or interviews, but would need an official escort at all times. The Times and one of its reporters brought a separate lawsuit, arguing that this rule punished their reporting and their earlier court victory. They say planned, escorted visits are no substitute for spontaneous conversations with sources. The district judge found their retaliation claim likely to succeed and granted a preliminary injunction, an initial order to block the requirement while the case proceeds. The government will defend the requirement as a security measure for a military facility that is not open to the general public. The Times will respond that the security explanation is a pretext, and that the rule takes away a vital part of newsgathering. Listen for two questions: can a rule applying to all reporters still retaliate against protected speech, and how much interference with reporting is enough to deter a person of ordinary firmness?
New York Times Company v. DOD (No. 26-5253) — U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit, argued November 16, 2026.
- 0:00Introduction