Jane Doe v. Todd Blanche — D.C. Cir. (Nov 20, 2026)
The District of Columbia Circuit hears a dispute over the planned transfer of transgender women from women's federal facilities to men's facilities. In January 2025, a new executive order directed that people the administration classifies as male not be housed in women's prisons. The Bureau of Prisons moved to apply that policy to transgender women it had previously placed in women's facilities. The plaintiffs say the transfers would expose them to serious violence and severe psychological harm. Their suit invokes the Eighth Amendment's ban on cruel and unusual punishment. A district judge blocked their transfers. An earlier appeal required the judge to examine each plaintiff's circumstances, and the judge then issued a new preliminary injunction. The temporary orders protect the named plaintiffs during litigation, rather than finally deciding the policy's lawfulness. The government will argue that a no-exceptions rule based on biological sex is constitutionally reasonable, and that selected men's medical facilities and safety measures can protect the plaintiffs. Their lawyer will argue that the judge's individualized findings show those measures are inadequate for these particular people. The court will also hear a friend-of-the-court lawyer presenting other women prisoners' privacy and safety concerns. A separate case has already produced an order requiring separation inside one women's facility. Listen for how that arrangement affects the dispute, and whether keeping the plaintiffs in women's facilities necessarily means housing them with other inmates. The hearing also starts with a timing question: what happens to the appeal if the temporary injunction expires before it can be decided?
Jane Doe v. Todd Blanche (No. 26-5238) — U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit, argued November 20, 2026.
- 0:00Introduction