Todd Harper v. Scott Bessent — D.C. Cir. (Nov 17, 2026)
The D.C. Circuit considers whether the President can remove members of the National Credit Union Administration’s board at will. The agency supervises credit unions, insures their members’ accounts, and provides emergency liquidity. In April 2025, President Trump removed two board members, Todd Harper and Tanya Otsuka, before their appointed terms had ended. They sued to return to office. The district court held that the law protected them from removal without cause and ordered agency officials to let them carry out their duties. The government challenges that ruling. The unusual feature is that the statute does not expressly say board members may be removed only for cause. But in 1978, Congress replaced a single administrator with a multimember board and deleted language saying the leadership served at the President’s pleasure. The members say those changes were meant to protect the agency’s independence; the government says they do not override the President’s removal authority. The government’s lawyer will argue that the missing express restriction is decisive, and that the agency’s rulemaking and enforcement powers require presidential control. The members’ lawyer will argue that Congress’s design provides protection, and that the agency’s role as a financial backstop places it in a historical tradition of independent banking institutions. Listen for two separate questions: did Congress limit removal, and if it did, does the Constitution permit that limit? The judges will test whether the agency is genuinely comparable to the Federal Reserve, or whether supervising credit unions is different from the Fed’s distinctive monetary role.
Todd Harper v. Scott Bessent (No. 25-5268) — U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit, argued November 17, 2026.
- 0:00Introduction