LeBlanc v. Privacy and Civil Liberties Oversight Board — D.C. Cir. (Nov 17, 2026)
The D.C. Circuit considers whether the President could remove members of a federal privacy watchdog without showing cause. The Privacy and Civil Liberties Oversight Board reviews counterterrorism programs and advises Congress and the executive branch about their effects on privacy and civil liberties. Two members refused White House requests to resign and were told that their positions had been terminated in January 2025. They sued, and a federal judge held the removals unlawful and ordered officials other than the President to treat them as still serving. The government appealed. The case turns on a 2007 rewrite of the Board’s statute. Congress made it a separate independent agency and deleted language saying members served at the President’s pleasure, but did not add an express for-cause removal clause. The government’s lawyer will argue that this silence leaves the President free to remove members, and that the Board’s advisory role is still an executive function. The former members’ lawyer will argue that the statutory changes and watchdog mission make protection from arbitrary removal clear, without particular magic words. Even if the removals were unlawful, the lawyers dispute whether an ordinary injunction is available, or whether the members must satisfy the stricter test for mandamus—a special order compelling an official to act. Listen for the difference between the power to fire, the independence Congress designed, and the court’s power to provide a practical remedy.
LeBlanc v. Privacy and Civil Liberties Oversight Board (No. 25-5197) — U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit, argued November 17, 2026.
- 0:00Introduction