United States v. Jonathan R. Pinkerton — CAAF (Nov 17, 2026)
The Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces reviews an Army court-martial arising from allegations that a soldier sexually abused his two young daughters. The prosecution relied on a recorded forensic interview in which one daughter described alleged abuse. At trial, by then seven years old, she took the oath, said she loved her father, and refused to discuss what had happened. Defense counsel declined cross-examination. The military judge admitted her recorded interview, and the court-martial convicted the soldier of child-sex offenses. The Army Court of Criminal Appeals affirmed. The question here is whether admitting that interview violated his constitutional right to confront witnesses. The defense will argue that a witness who refuses to discuss the allegations provides no meaningful opportunity for questioning. The government will contend that she was available to answer questions and that declining to ask them cannot establish a denial of confrontation. This Court agreed to review the confrontation issue, not the separate evidentiary challenge to admitting the recording.
United States v. Jonathan R. Pinkerton (No. 26-0225/AR) — United States Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces, argued November 17, 2026.
- 0:00Introduction