Cottonwood Environmental Law Center v. Yellowstone Mountain Club — 9th Cir. (Nov 20, 2026)
The Ninth Circuit hears a water-pollution dispute involving Yellowstone Mountain Club's golf course. Cottonwood Environmental Law Center alleges that pollution from the property reaches the Gallatin River. The part at issue here concerns a pond at the fourth hole, used as a water hazard. Cottonwood investigated the property and relied on scientific testing and expert analysis to support its case. But before trial, the district judge rejected its Hole Four claim under the Clean Water Act because he concluded that claim was not pleaded in the complaint. Cottonwood now wants it sent back for trial. One complication is that an earlier request to change the complaint concerned a public-nuisance claim, distinct from the federal water-pollution claim. Cottonwood will argue that the club had fair notice and that the court's earlier discussion of expert disputes contemplated a trial. The club will argue that Cottonwood is advancing a different water-flow theory that it never properly added to the lawsuit. Listen for the difference between investigating a possible pollution pathway and bringing that particular claim into the case. What was pleaded, what did the district court actually decide, and what arguments were preserved for this appeal?
Cottonwood Environmental Law Center v. Yellowstone Mountain Club (No. 26-779) — U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, argued November 20, 2026.
- 0:00Introduction