Kelly, II v. Arizona Medical Board, et al. — 9th Cir. (Nov 19, 2026)
The Ninth Circuit hears a physician's challenge to the way Arizona disciplined his medical license. Charles Kelly practiced medicine in Arizona. During disciplinary proceedings, the Medical Board imposed an interim agreement setting conditions on his practice, including monitoring and record-keeping requirements. Disputes over compliance led to a suspension and, later, probation. Kelly contends that the Board and its staff discriminated against him because of race and disability; they dispute his account. Instead of obtaining state-court review of those disciplinary decisions, Kelly brought a federal civil-rights suit. The district court dismissed it under claim preclusion, also called res judicata: the principle that a matter cannot be litigated again after a binding final decision. That sets up the central disagreement. Does Arizona law bar a later suit only when it relies on the same evidence as the earlier proceeding, or more broadly when it grows out of the same underlying events? And do the finality rules for administrative decisions answer that question separately? Kelly's lawyer will argue that existing Arizona Supreme Court precedent preserves the narrower test, and that this discrimination suit requires different proof. The Board's lawyer will argue that Kelly had an opportunity to raise his objections through the disciplinary process and state judicial review, and cannot bring a collateral challenge now. Listen for the judges' distinction between disagreement with the discipline itself and a separate claim of discrimination—and whether Arizona's own Supreme Court should clarify the governing rule.
Kelly, II v. Arizona Medical Board, et al. (No. 26-213) — U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, argued November 19, 2026.
- 0:00Introduction