Smith, et al. v. California Apartment Association, et al. — 9th Cir. (Nov 18, 2026)
The Ninth Circuit considers who can join an Oakland rent-control lawsuit. Renters with mobility disabilities sued the city because the accessible apartments they need generally fall outside its rent-control protections. The program covers older housing, while most accessible units were built later. The renters want those protections extended to qualifying newer housing as a disability accommodation. That proposal runs into California's Costa-Hawkins law, which protects certain newer housing from local rent control. The California Apartment Association asked to join as a defendant to defend that law and its members' financial interests. The district court refused, finding the request too late and the existing parties adequate to represent those interests. The association will argue that the need to intervene only became clear later, and that its interests differ from the city's. The renters will argue it waited too long and the existing defendants can protect those interests. Listen for the difference between knowing a lawsuit exists and knowing your interests need a separate voice.
Smith, et al. v. California Apartment Association, et al. (No. 26-1648) — U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, argued November 18, 2026.
- 0:00Introduction