Cottonwood Environmental Law Center, et al. v. Big Sky Water and Sewer District, et al. — 9th Cir. (Nov 20, 2026)
The Ninth Circuit considers Cottonwood versus the Big Sky Water and Sewer District, a Clean Water Act dispute over wastewater reaching a Montana river. Cottonwood alleged pollution from the district's storage ponds and irrigation at a nearby golf course. A key dispute was how much water leaked from the ponds, rather than being pumped out for irrigation elsewhere. After a jury ruled for the district, Cottonwood asked the judge to reopen the judgment. It alleged that important water-export data had been concealed in hidden Excel tabs. The judge rejected that claim, finding the data had been disclosed and was not falsified. The judge also imposed attorneys' fees and a restriction on further motions. Cottonwood's lawyer will argue that the way the spreadsheets were produced prevented a fair challenge to the data, and that the judge mishandled the later EPA investigation. The district's lawyer will defend the court's findings. There is also a separate golf-course claim involving Boyne. Listen for whether the jury could consider other possible pollution sources, and whether Cottonwood properly objected to that instruction at trial.
Cottonwood Environmental Law Center, et al. v. Big Sky Water and Sewer District, et al. (No. 25-7929) — U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, argued November 20, 2026.
- 0:00Introduction