Melton v. County of Maricopa, et al. — 9th Cir. (Nov 19, 2026)
The Ninth Circuit hears Melton versus the County of Maricopa. Kayla Melton's husband was shot and killed by sheriff's deputies. She brought a civil-rights lawsuit alleging that the county failed to train its deputies to de-escalate a suicidal crisis, and that this failure deprived her family of their relationship with him. The appeal concerns the county's own training responsibilities, not an individual damages claim against each deputy. You will hear the term Monell. It means the county is not liable merely because it employs an officer who violates someone's rights. The injury must be connected to the county's own policy or custom. A failure to train can qualify, but it must amount to deliberate indifference, not just negligence, and must actually cause the constitutional harm. The family will rely on the narrow possibility of proving an obvious training need without a pattern of earlier incidents. Listen for the difference between evidence of inadequate training and disagreement about how officers applied training they received. The discussion will focus on supervising an encounter, responding to a suicidal person, and warnings before a less-lethal shot. The judges will also test causation: whether an identified training gap, rather than something else, explains the fatal outcome. Keep those two questions separate as the court considers whether the evidence can support holding the county itself responsible.
Melton v. County of Maricopa, et al. (No. 25-6291) — U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, argued November 19, 2026.
- 0:00Introduction