Kidd, et al. v. Mullin, et al. — 9th Cir. (Nov 19, 2026)
The Ninth Circuit hears the government's appeal over ICE arrests at people's homes. In the Los Angeles area, officers used visits called knock and talks to reach residents at home. Some residents were asked to step outside and were immediately arrested. Officers typically lacked a judge-issued warrant, often carrying an arrest warrant issued by immigration officials instead. Two immigrant-rights organizations challenged this practice in a class action. A federal judge ruled in twenty twenty-four that entering protected home property to make these arrests, without a judicial warrant, valid consent, or another legal basis, violated the Fourth Amendment and immigration regulations. The judge set aside the policy in the Los Angeles enforcement area. Curtilage means the area immediately surrounding a home, such as a porch or enclosed yard. The dispute is whether the ordinary visitor's permission to approach a front door extends to a planned arrest. The government will argue that these contacts are lawful, that administrative arrest warrants can suffice for immigration enforcement, and that the organizations have not shown the injury needed to sue. The organizations will argue that these were arrest operations, not mere conversations, and that their members face a real risk if the policy returns. The judges will also consider a litigation agreement: the government had promised not to use administrative warrants to justify entering protected home property. The parties now dispute whether the government must be held to that promise.
Kidd, et al. v. Mullin, et al. (No. 25-4864) — U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, argued November 19, 2026.
- 0:00Introduction