Myers, et al. v. Sazerac Company, Inc. — 9th Cir. (Nov 19, 2026)
The Ninth Circuit hears a consumer class action against Sazerac over Fireball. The buyers say the small bottles of Fireball Malt looked so much like Fireball Whisky that they thought they were buying whisky, rather than a lower-alcohol malt beverage. Their claim is that the packaging misled them into paying more than the product was worth. The district court certified a class, allowing buyers to pursue their claims together. Sazerac now challenges that decision, focusing on how the consumers propose to estimate their losses. You will hear about conjoint analysis: a survey that asks people to choose among products with different features and prices, to measure what they value. The difficult question is how those preferences translate into a market price, where sellers as well as buyers affect what a product costs. Sazerac will argue that the proposed model does not reliably account for how sellers would respond if buyers knew exactly what the drink contained. The consumers will counter that historical sales prices and their proposed market simulation can account for that side of the market. The survey has not yet been run. Listen for what the judges think must be demonstrated now, before the case proceeds as a class action. This hearing is about that procedural decision and the proposed damages method, not a final ruling that the label was unlawful or that a particular amount is owed.
Myers, et al. v. Sazerac Company, Inc. (No. 25-4833) — U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, argued November 19, 2026.
- 0:00Introduction