In re: Blackwell, et al. v. Porcel — 9th Cir. (Nov 19, 2026)
The Ninth Circuit hears Blackwell's appeal over a wrongful-death lawsuit and her bankruptcy discharge. In twenty twenty, her car struck the back of a stopped vehicle in Washington, pushing it into oncoming traffic. A passenger died. His mother later sued Blackwell, another driver, and Washington state. But Blackwell had obtained a bankruptcy discharge, protecting her from personal collection on the discharged debt. The mother wants to continue the suit to reach insurance and to establish possible liability of the other defendants. A bankruptcy judge barred the litigation against Blackwell, but an intermediate bankruptcy appeals panel reversed. Keeping Blackwell in the case matters to the estate's theory of joint and several liability. Under that theory, other defendants could have to pay damages attributable to Blackwell. Whether the lawsuit can proceed without violating her discharge is the dispute you will hear. Blackwell's lawyer will argue that entering a money judgment against her is inconsistent with her discharge. The estate's lawyer will argue that the suit may proceed so long as Blackwell cannot be made to pay personally. Listen for the difference between determining liability and enforcing a judgment.
In re: Blackwell, et al. v. Porcel (No. 25-4236) — U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, argued November 19, 2026.
- 0:00Introduction