Reyes v. Apple Inc. — 9th Cir. (Nov 17, 2026)
The Ninth Circuit reviews the exclusion of a medical expert in a family's case against Apple. A boy identified in court as B G was wearing an AirPods Pro earbud when an Amber Alert sounded. His family says the sound caused permanent hearing loss in his right ear. Apple disputes that explanation. The district judge excluded the family's causation expert and granted summary judgment for Apple. Without admissible evidence of causation, the case could not go to trial. General causation asks whether this kind of sound exposure can cause the injury claimed. Specific causation asks whether it actually caused this child's injury. The family's lawyer will argue that the doctor's clinical experience and comparison of possible causes gave a reliable basis for his opinion. Apple's lawyer will argue that the opinion lacked scientific support and did not reliably rule out a viral infection. Keep qualifications and reliability separate. Medical training and experience concern a witness's qualifications; the soundness of the reasoning behind a particular opinion is a different question. The appeal asks whether that testimony was reliable enough for a jury to hear.
Reyes v. Apple Inc. (No. 25-3309) — United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, argued November 17, 2026.
- 0:00Introduction