Ashli Healthcare, Inc. v. Kennedy — 9th Cir. (Nov 18, 2026)
The Ninth Circuit considers whether a Medicare supplier had a fair chance to challenge an audit that produced a repayment demand exceeding a million dollars. Ashli Healthcare supplies medical equipment to Medicare patients. A contractor reviewed a sample of ninety claims, found overpayments, and projected those findings across a larger group of claims. Ashli successfully challenged some payment denials during administrative appeals, reducing the demand. But it sued the health secretary, saying it still lacked the information needed to check the audit and the government’s recovery of the money. The district court ruled for the government, and Ashli appealed. Both sides agree Ashli received the list of claims remaining after certain claims were filtered out. The dispute concerns the earlier data showing what was excluded, support for later recalculations, and an accounting of repayments and interest. Ashli’s lawyer will argue that without these materials, the company cannot reproduce the statistical work or meaningfully challenge the debt. The government’s lawyer will argue that Ashli already has the data needed to check the calculations, and that excluded claims did not determine the repayment demand. Listen for the difference between checking the arithmetic and testing how the audit group was assembled—and whether the available procedures offered a meaningful chance to be heard.
Ashli Healthcare, Inc. v. Kennedy (No. 25-3168) — U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, argued November 18, 2026.
- 0:00Introduction