USA v. Holt — 9th Cir. (Nov 19, 2026)
The Ninth Circuit hears the consolidated criminal appeals of Zachary Holt and a co-defendant. The case grew out of a series of robberies and shootings in Idaho and eastern Washington. During an attempted robbery on the Colville Reservation in twenty twenty-two, two people were killed. Holt later shot at pursuing police. A jury convicted him and his co-defendant of multiple crimes; both received life sentences. The main legal question you will hear concerns a voluntary-intoxication instruction: whether jurors should have been told how alcohol or drug use could bear on the intent required for particular charges. Intoxication is not a blanket excuse for crime. In a specific-intent prosecution, though, evidence of intoxication may bear on whether the government has proved the necessary state of mind. Listen for the difference between evidence that someone consumed drugs or alcohol and evidence relevant to their ability to form that intent. A separate dispute concerns a robbery committed in Idaho. The stolen property was taken across state lines weeks later. The Hobbs Act requires a connection to interstate commerce. Listen for whether that later movement can supply the connection for the robbery itself.
USA v. Holt (No. 25-1247) — U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, argued November 19, 2026.
- 0:00Introduction