Siren Retail Corporation dba Starbucks v. National Labor Relations Board — 9th Cir. (Nov 20, 2026)
The Ninth Circuit hears Siren Retail, doing business as Starbucks, versus the National Labor Relations Board. The dispute grew out of a union organizing campaign. Managers met with employees to discuss what union representation would mean. Statements about losing benefits, access to temporary assignments, and obligations to join a union or participate in a strike led to unfair labor practice charges. The Board found several statements unlawful threats, not merely protected opinions. Separately, it overruled a precedent called Tri-Cast, which concerned statements about how unionization changes employees' relationship with management. That new standard applied only to future conduct; the Board did not use it to find those relationship statements unlawful in this case. Starbucks will challenge the threat findings and argue that federal labor law and the First Amendment protect its speech. It will also argue that the prospective rule chills what it can say in future organizing campaigns. The Board and the union will defend the findings that the actual statements threatened employees. Listen for two distinct questions: which statements crossed the line from persuasion to threats, and whether Starbucks can challenge a new rule that was not applied against it.
Siren Retail Corporation dba Starbucks v. National Labor Relations Board (No. 24-6926) — U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, argued November 20, 2026.
- 0:00Introduction