Michael Arquero v. City of Chicago — 7th Cir. (Nov 17, 2026)
The Seventh Circuit hears a challenge to a police shooting on a Chicago street. Officers encountered Michael Arquero firing a handgun into an occupied car. Within seconds, they shot and wounded him. He then sued the officers and the city over the use of force. The central dispute concerns roughly three seconds after he turned toward the police. Arquero says he dropped the gun and was surrendering before the officers fired. Parts of the encounter are hidden behind a parked car in a video that both sides rely on. The district judge ruled for the officers without a trial, concluding their response was reasonable and they were protected by qualified immunity. Arquero's lawyer will argue that testimony and the video leave a factual dispute that a jury should resolve. The defense lawyer will argue that the officers faced an immediate threat and had no clearly established legal duty to respond differently in those few seconds. Listen for the distinction between whether the gun was dropped and whether the officers could reasonably recognize that any threat had ended. The judges will also examine how much an unclear video can resolve at this stage.
Michael Arquero v. City of Chicago (No. 25-1725) — U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit, argued November 17, 2026.
- 0:00Introduction