Christopher Scruggs v. Jason Smiley — 7th Cir. (Nov 17, 2026)
The Seventh Circuit hears Scruggs versus Smiley, a challenge to a prison disciplinary conviction for possessing a cellphone. During a prison search, an investigator reported finding a phone between towels in Scruggs's cell and an altered charger among his legal papers. Scruggs disputes where the phone was originally found. He says conflicting times and locations in the paperwork make the evidence unreliable. The prison found him guilty, and a federal district judge denied his habeas petition challenging that decision. The judge concluded that a conduct report, a photograph and a written video summary provided enough evidence. This is not a new criminal trial. The question is whether the disciplinary decision meets the constitutional floor called the some-evidence standard, and whether Scruggs received the process he was due. His lawyer will argue that the paperwork cannot reliably establish possession and that withheld video and a missing inmate-witness statement undermine the proceeding. The state's lawyer will argue that the investigator's account is sufficient, that security concerns justify withholding the video, and that any procedural error did not affect the result. Keep the written summary separate from the recording itself: the judges will question what the disciplinary decisionmaker actually considered.
Christopher Scruggs v. Jason Smiley (No. 24-3176) — United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit, argued November 17, 2026.
- 0:00Introduction