⚖ Oral Arguments, with Context

Real court arguments, crisp audio, with context.

Court recordings can be difficult to follow, and many suffer from poor audio quality. This podcast enhances the audio, provides a brief introduction to each case, and explains legal concepts that may be unfamiliar to some listeners.

We hope these enhancements make oral argument recordings easier to understand, more accessible, and more enjoyable to listen to.

Apple Podcasts Spotify YouTube /feed.xml Open RSS Status

Robert Woodall v. Laura Plappert — 6th Cir. (Nov 19, 2026)

No. 09-5352 Argued November 19, 2026 Published November 20, 2026

The Sixth Circuit returns to Robert Woodall's challenge to a Kentucky death sentence. The case began with the 1997 rape and murder of a teenage girl. Woodall was sentenced to death after a jury proceeding over punishment. The questions now concern how that jury was selected, and the instructions it received. During jury selection, the prosecution removed the last Black person remaining in the pool. The defense objected. The prosecutor pointed to answers on her questionnaire, including a statement that she did not trust anyone. The trial judge noted the objection and moved on without an express finding about whether that explanation was genuine. Among its rulings, a federal district court granted relief on the jury-selection claim, but rejected a separate challenge to the penalty instructions. Both sides are appealing those parts of the decision. You will hear the state warden's lawyer first. He will argue that the trial judge implicitly rejected the race-discrimination claim, and that the Kentucky Supreme Court's review deserves deference. Woodall's lawyer will argue that merely noting the objection was not enough: the trial judge had to make the critical credibility finding. The second issue is whether a juror could consider a reason for a lesser sentence without everyone agreeing on it. Woodall will argue that the instructions blurred that distinction; the state will defend them as permissible. Listen for the difference between a unanimous sentencing verdict and each juror's ability to consider mitigating evidence.

Robert Woodall v. Laura Plappert (No. 09-5352) — U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit, argued November 19, 2026.

0:00
0:00