Collins v. Applegreen CT Travel Plazas, LLC — 2d Cir. (Nov 17, 2026)
The Second Circuit considers whether a company can be liable for failing to protect an employee from sex-based harassment by someone who works for a different business. Collins worked at a Dunkin' Donuts inside a Connecticut highway service plaza. Her complaint alleges that the manager of the Mobil Mart in the same building pulled her ears, repeatedly threw objects at her, and mocked her work with a remark about showing her how a man would do the job. She says she reported his behavior to Applegreen, her employer, but managers told her to ignore him or seek a restraining order. Applegreen later fired her, citing a cash shortage that she disputed. Collins sued for harassment and other employment claims. A federal judge dismissed her complaint before trial, finding insufficient allegations that Applegreen controlled the alleged harasser or knew the harassment was sex-based. The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, appearing in support of Collins, will argue that the focus should be Applegreen's own failure to respond, not whether the other business's manager was its employee or agent. Applegreen's lawyer will argue that the lack of control and the absence of sufficient allegations of sex-based conduct defeat the claim. Listen for the difference between responsibility for someone else's actions and responsibility for ignoring a problem in your own workplace. This is a pleading dispute: the judges are deciding whether Collins has alleged enough to pursue the case, not whether she has proved what happened. Recording note: The official audio cuts off a final hesitation after the court says it will reserve decision. Both sides' arguments are complete; the original ending is preserved without reconstructed speech.
Collins v. Applegreen CT Travel Plazas, LLC (No. 26-846) — United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, argued November 17, 2026.
- 0:00Introduction