Lissa Hostomsky, et al. v. David Burgess, et al. — 11th Cir. (Nov 18, 2026)
The Eleventh Circuit considers a civil-rights suit arising from a police encounter that ended in a fatal shooting. On December twenty-ninth, twenty twenty-two, Edward Townsend was visiting his mother in Florida. According to the family’s complaint, he called nine-one-one for help recovering his car keys after a dispute with relatives. Deputy David Burgess tried to handcuff him, and another deputy, Ashlyn Whelchel, joined the encounter. What followed included physical force, a Taser, and gunfire. The family says Townsend posed no deadly threat; the deputies describe resistance and a struggle over a Taser. His estate sued, challenging not just the shooting, but the initial detention and earlier uses of force. The deputies now appeal the district court’s refusal to grant them qualified immunity, a protection that turns on both constitutional rights and whether the law was clearly established. Their lawyer will argue that reported threats involving a gun justified the detention, and that the later struggle gave the officers reason to fear serious harm. The estate’s lawyer will argue that the encounter escalated unjustifiably, and that disputed evidence, including Townsend’s mother’s testimony, cannot simply be rejected on appeal. Listen for two separate questions: what each officer could reasonably do at each stage, and which factual disputes an appeals court can resolve before a trial. The judges will also probe whether earlier decisions clearly warned the deputies that their particular actions were unlawful, even if the estate’s account is accepted.
Lissa Hostomsky, et al. v. David Burgess, et al. (No. 25-14117) — U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit, argued November 18, 2026.
- 0:00Introduction