Alyssa Russo v. Progressive Select Insurance Company — 11th Cir. (Nov 16, 2026)
The Eleventh Circuit hears an insurance appeal arising from a collision with a United States postal vehicle. The injured driver sought compensation from the United States and uninsured-motorist benefits from her own insurer, Progressive. The district court dismissed the insurer on the pleadings, before trial. It reasoned that compensation available under the Federal Tort Claims Act left no uninsured loss for Progressive to cover. That Act permits certain negligence claims against the federal government. The driver's lawyer will argue that the court should have accepted her allegation that no insurance policy or bond covered the vehicle. He will also argue that an exclusion elsewhere in the contract cannot be imported into uninsured-motorist coverage. Progressive will defend the judgment, arguing that federal liability rules and limits on duplicate recovery leave no additional insurance benefits payable. Listen for a distinction beneath the coverage dispute: which allegations are facts the court must accept at this stage, and which are legal conclusions it need not accept. A reversal would let the claim continue; it would not itself establish how much, if anything, Progressive must pay.
Alyssa Russo v. Progressive Select Insurance Company (No. 25-13565) — United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit, argued November 16, 2026.
- 0:00Introduction