Dugan, et al. v. CIR — 10th Cir. (Nov 16, 2026)
The Tenth Circuit considers whether two taxpayers can get their tax dispute heard after missing a filing deadline. The IRS said they owed additional income tax. They petitioned the Tax Court to contest that demand, but their petition was late. The Tax Court dismissed the case without deciding whether the tax demand was correct. They offered explanations for the delay, but the judge concluded that the deadline left the court no power to make an exception. They appealed. The ordinary deadline is ninety days after the IRS mails its notice, not ninety days after the taxpayer receives it. Their lawyer will argue that Congress did not clearly make this deadline jurisdictional, meaning a limit on the court's power to hear a case. She will also seek recognition of equitable tolling: allowing a late filing in appropriate exceptional circumstances. The government will defend a strict deadline, arguing that the tax system's interconnected assessment and collection rules depend on it. There are two separate questions: whether the deadline limits jurisdiction, and, even if it does not, whether equitable tolling is available. The taxpayers are not asking this panel to excuse their particular delay outright; they want the Tax Court to be allowed to consider that question.
Dugan, et al. v. CIR (No. 26-9002) — United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit, argued November 16, 2026.
- 0:00Introduction