Vanlandingham v. Lee, et al. — 10th Cir. (Nov 17, 2026)
The Tenth Circuit considers an Oklahoma City police officer’s role in a man’s death during a medical emergency. In September 2019, an emergency call brought paramedics to help Charles Vanlandingham. Firefighters were already trying to restrain him when Officer Brandon Lee arrived to assist. Lee handcuffed him, then placed his shin across his back while others held him face down. Paramedics administered a sedative; Vanlandingham became unresponsive and died at the scene. His estate sued, claiming the continued force was unlawful after he was already restrained. The district judge allowed excessive-force and conspiracy claims to proceed, and Lee appealed. Lee seeks qualified immunity, which can protect officers against personal liability when their conduct did not violate clearly established law. The dispute centers on continued pressure during the restraint, not the initial use of handcuffs. Lee’s lawyer will argue that he reasonably relied on trained medical personnel who were treating the patient and did not tell him to stop. The estate’s lawyer will argue that existing restraint cases gave clear warning against adding weight once a person was subdued, even when medical staff were present. Listen for the difference between deciding whether force was excessive and deciding whether prior cases gave sufficiently clear notice in this medical setting. Also listen for whether the responders’ coordinated actions show an agreement to use unlawful force, and which disputed facts the appeals court can reconsider before trial.
Vanlandingham v. Lee, et al. (No. 26-6065) — U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit, argued November 17, 2026.
- 0:00Introduction