Hsieh v. Surratt, et al. — 10th Cir. (Nov 17, 2026)
The Tenth Circuit considers a medical student’s suspension over statements made to a mental-health crisis line. The student attended the University of Oklahoma. During crisis-line contacts in the spring of 2024, she made statements that the university interpreted as threats of harm to herself and administrators. Crisis-line personnel alerted the university, which treated the statements as threats and imposed a one-year suspension after a disciplinary hearing. She sued, saying the university punished protected speech made while she sought help. The trial court allowed her First Amendment claims against individual administrators to proceed, and those officials appealed. The immediate issue is qualified immunity: whether the officials can avoid personal liability for money damages because the law was not clearly established when they acted. Their lawyer will argue that the Supreme Court’s criminal true-threat ruling did not clearly establish the rules for university discipline. The student’s lawyer will argue that officials needed to show she consciously disregarded the risk of her words being taken as threats, not simply that they were alarming. Listen for the difference between criminal prosecution and school discipline, and whether campus disruption provides a separate justification for the university’s response.
Hsieh v. Surratt, et al. (No. 26-6052) — U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit, argued November 17, 2026.
- 0:00Introduction