Schau v. Trisura Specialty Insurance Company — 10th Cir. (Nov 16, 2026)
The Tenth Circuit considers whether an Oklahoma insurance dispute belongs in court or private arbitration. Schau submitted a claim for wind damage to commercial property in Oklahoma City. He sued his insurers, alleging they wrongfully denied coverage and handled the claim in bad faith. The insurers deny those allegations and invoke an arbitration clause in the policy. The district court refused to compel arbitration, and the insurers appealed. Oklahoma law generally excludes insurance contracts from its arbitration statute. A federal law, the McCarran-Ferguson Act, can protect state insurance rules against conflicting federal statutes not specifically about insurance. The insurers will argue that the New York Convention, an international arbitration treaty, itself requires arbitration and is not displaced by Oklahoma law. Schau will argue that the treaty needs implementing legislation, which must give way to Oklahoma's insurance rule. There is also a threshold question: should the court or the arbitrator decide the arbitration issue? This hearing concerns where and by whom the dispute should be decided, not whether the storm claim must be paid.
Schau v. Trisura Specialty Insurance Company (No. 26-6050) — United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit, argued November 16, 2026.
- 0:00Introduction