State of Utah v. Express Scripts — 10th Cir. (Nov 17, 2026)
The Tenth Circuit hears Utah versus Express Scripts. Utah sued Express Scripts, Optum, and related companies in state court over their alleged role in the opioid crisis. These pharmacy benefit managers help health plans decide which prescription drugs are covered and on what terms. Utah alleges they favored opioids in exchange for payments from manufacturers, while failing to curb dangerous prescribing. The companies also serve military, veterans', and federal-employee health plans. They moved the lawsuit to federal court under the federal-officer removal law. Utah says its complaint expressly excludes their federal work. The district judge accepted that limitation and sent the case back to state court. The companies' lawyer will argue that joint rebate negotiations and shared drug lists cannot be divided neatly between federal and private business. Utah's lawyer will argue that the claims target non-federal conduct and can remain in state court. There is also a second question: must the case pause automatically while the companies appeal the choice of court, or must they qualify for a discretionary stay? Listen for the difference between deciding where the lawsuit belongs and deciding whether Utah can prove the alleged harm.
State of Utah v. Express Scripts (No. 26-4035) — U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit, argued November 17, 2026.
- 0:00Introduction