Lyman v. Henderson — 10th Cir. (Nov 17, 2026)
The Tenth Circuit hears Lyman versus Henderson. In 2024, Utah voter Phil Lyman asked the lieutenant governor's office for the state's full voter registration database. His request included birth years and records classified as private or withheld under state law. The office directed him to the public version, but declined unrestricted access, citing Utah's disclosure restrictions. Lyman sued under the National Voter Registration Act, arguing that federal disclosure requirements override those limits. He says he needs the records to check voter-list accuracy and propose improvements. The district court dismissed the case in January 2026 for lack of standing: it found no concrete personal harm beyond being denied the information. That ruling did not decide whether federal law actually requires disclosure of these records. Now Lyman is appealing. His lawyer will argue that denial of records required to be public is itself an injury, and that the refusal obstructs his election oversight. The state's lawyer will argue that he must show a specific, personal consequence, not simply an interest in ensuring the government follows the law. Listen for that distinction between a right to information and the constitutional requirements for bringing a federal lawsuit.
Lyman v. Henderson (No. 26-4014) — U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit, argued November 17, 2026.
- 0:00Introduction