Methods Research v. Ottawa Bancshares, et al. — 10th Cir. (Nov 16, 2026)
A banking consultant asks whether the banks that hired it must pay an additional performance fee. Methods Research helped a group of banks consolidate information technology and improve their operations. Their written agreement provided for fixed payments and a further fee tied to financial improvements from the consultant's recommendations. The fixed payments were made, but the performance fee became a dispute. One flashpoint was a signing bonus from Mastercard, whose contract the consultant had negotiated. The consultant billed a fee tied to that bonus, and the parties disagreed about expenses, measurement, and how to account for payments already made. Methods Research sued, also accusing the banks of making misleading representations about the fee calculations. The federal trial judge ruled for the banks before trial, finding the performance-fee provision too indefinite to enforce and rejecting the remaining claims. The consultant is now appealing. Its lawyer will argue that the parties made a real bargain and that a jury can resolve uncertainties about what the words mean. The banks' lawyer will argue that essential pricing terms were never agreed upon, and that a court cannot write those terms for the parties. Listen for the difference between interpreting an uncertain agreement and supplying a missing agreement. There are also questions about the consultant's opportunity to respond before its misrepresentation claim was dismissed, and about access to financial records.
Methods Research v. Ottawa Bancshares, et al. (No. 26-3058) — United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit, argued November 16, 2026.
- 0:00Introduction