Defending Education v. Sullivan — 10th Cir. (Nov 16, 2026)
The Tenth Circuit hears Defending Education versus Sullivan and two related appeals over Colorado's anti-discrimination law. Advocacy groups, medical plaintiffs, an athletic-clothing retailer and a Christian bookstore challenged the law after a 2025 amendment expressly included chosen names and forms of address in its protections. They want to use names and pronouns consistent with their beliefs about biological sex, including when dealing with transgender customers or members of the public. The retailers say they will serve everyone, but fear that a complaint about their speech could trigger enforcement. They sued before any enforcement against them, claiming the law chills speech and compels words they reject. The district court denied temporary injunctions, finding no sufficiently credible enforcement threat. A later ruling let several plaintiffs continue litigating, while dismissing three advocacy groups for lack of standing. Standing means the right to bring a concrete dispute into federal court; it is separate from whether a law is constitutional. The plaintiffs will argue that their self-censorship and the risk of complaints justify protection now. Colorado will argue that speech alone does not establish the discrimination or harassment required, and that its enforcement assurances remove the claimed threat. Listen for why standing to continue a lawsuit might differ from standing to obtain temporary relief, and whether the appeals court should order an injunction or send that question back.
Defending Education v. Sullivan (No. 26-1101) — United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit, argued November 16, 2026.
- 0:00Introduction