Brank Cove Capital, et al. v. CIR — 10th Cir. (Nov 16, 2026)
The Tenth Circuit hears Brank Cove Capital versus the Commissioner of Internal Revenue over a charitable tax deduction for mountain land near Asheville, North Carolina. The partnership donated a conservation easement, giving up development rights to preserve the land. To value that donation, it treated a planned fifty-cabin vacation resort as the land's highest and best use: its most valuable feasible use. The IRS disputed that development plan, citing steep terrain, building restrictions, and problems with access and utilities. The Tax Court instead adopted a lower-density residential, recreation, and timber use, resulting in a much smaller deduction. A key dispute concerns the partnership's appraisal: its author did not testify, and the Tax Court would not accept the report as proof of its valuation. Brank Cove will argue that the report should have been admitted under the exception for business records and that the court wrongly discounted the property's development potential. The Commissioner will defend both the valuation findings and the exclusion of the untested appraisal. The partnership also challenges a forty-percent valuation-misstatement penalty on the resulting tax underpayment, including constitutional objections to that penalty.
Brank Cove Capital, et al. v. CIR (No. 25-9007) — U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit, argued November 16, 2026.
- 0:00Introduction