United States v. Smith — 10th Cir. (Nov 19, 2026)
The Tenth Circuit hears United States versus Smith. Smith was convicted of voluntary manslaughter after a man died from injuries sustained in a fight. Another participant, Gilbert, pleaded guilty before Smith's trial, admitting that she aided him in causing the death. Smith wanted the jury to hear her account of the fight, but the judge kept that part of her plea hearing out. This appeal asks whether that exclusion wrongly prevented Smith from presenting his defense. The lawyers will discuss statements against interest: a hearsay exception that can admit statements genuinely exposing their speaker to criminal liability. It requires an unavailable witness and corroborating circumstances clearly indicating the statement's trustworthiness. A guilty plea does not automatically make every part of the person's story admissible. A key question is whether the particular passage actually incriminated Gilbert or instead described justified conduct. Her having pleaded guilty does not automatically answer that question. The judges will examine both the context in which she spoke and the evidence supporting or undermining her account. Listen for the distinction between deciding whether evidence qualifies for admission and deciding what weight a jury should give it.
United States v. Smith (No. 25-7077) — U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit, argued November 19, 2026.
- 0:00Introduction