United States v. Butler — 10th Cir. (Nov 19, 2026)
The Tenth Circuit hears United States versus Butler, an appeal about how a jury was screened for bias in a sexual-assault prosecution. The prosecution arose from an accusation that Butler sexually assaulted another inmate at a federal transfer facility. A jury found him guilty. He now seeks a new trial over how that jury was selected. The defendant and the complainant were of different races. Before trial, the defense requested questions about racial prejudice, but the judge declined. A separate concern involved a prospective juror who disclosed having experienced sexual abuse. The judge refused the defense's request to remove that juror for cause. Butler's lawyer will argue that these decisions denied him an impartial jury. Listen for two questions: whether omitting racial-bias questions requires a new trial, and when a juror's own experiences require removal despite an assurance of fairness. The judges will press both sides on the difference between finding a defect in jury selection and deciding what to do about it. Pay particular attention to the debate over harmless error: whether the strength of the prosecution's evidence can answer a challenge about the fairness of the jury itself.
United States v. Butler (No. 25-6206) — U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit, argued November 19, 2026.
- 0:00Introduction