Morris v. Davis — 10th Cir. (Nov 17, 2026)
The Tenth Circuit asks whether an Oklahoma prisoner received fair notice of the crime he needed to defend against. Prosecutors alleged that Brent Morris repeatedly struck a woman in the head with a frying pan, causing serious injuries. Morris disputes that he was the assailant. The written charge called the offense assault and battery with intent to kill. But at the end of trial, the jury was instructed on assault using force likely to produce death, without requiring proof that Morris specifically intended to kill. The jury convicted him of that offense. The state appeals court upheld the conviction, and a federal judge later denied his petition for habeas corpus, the process for challenging unlawful custody. This appeal focuses on the notice issue, not a new trial about who committed the attack. Morris’s lawyer will argue that the charge and the way the case was tried told the defense to contest intent to kill, and that the theory changed too late for a fair defense. The state’s lawyer will argue that the factual allegations already described the offense submitted to the jury, and that the defense was not unfairly surprised. The judges must also consider the demanding standard for federal review of a state conviction: was the state court’s decision an unreasonable application of clearly established Supreme Court law? Listen for the difference between a misleading offense label and a change in the substance of the accusation—and for the separate dispute over whether Morris must show prejudice.
Morris v. Davis (No. 25-5044) — U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit, argued November 17, 2026.
- 0:00Introduction