Vitamins Online v. HeartWise — 10th Cir. (Nov 17, 2026)
The Tenth Circuit hears Vitamins Online versus HeartWise. This began as a false-advertising suit between two companies selling vitamins and supplements online. Vitamins Online won a money judgment, and HeartWise then entered bankruptcy. About fourteen and a half million dollars was deposited with the bankruptcy court to pay that judgment. But Vitamins Online and its former law firm, MCG, each claimed the right to collect it. Their fee agreement called for payments to go through the firm, which would deduct its fees and pass the balance to the client. In 2024, the Utah district court ruled that Vitamins Online had the collection right. The firm appealed, but that same judge later vacated the challenged orders. Now the threshold question is whether this court can hear the appeal at all. The firm's lawyer will seek dismissal, arguing that later developments leave no effective relief to grant. Vitamins Online's lawyer will argue that the appeal transferred authority to this court, preventing the district judge from undoing those orders. Listen for the difference between who receives the money first and who is ultimately entitled to keep it.
Vitamins Online v. HeartWise (No. 24-4110) — U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit, argued November 17, 2026.
- 0:00Introduction